syshen's blog

最近在網路上看到兩個短片，都是跟新聞媒體相關，其中一個是從 Bike 那裡看來的腳尾米，這是台灣學生自己製作的紀錄片，影片前半段剪輯了許多人的訪談，有廣電所老師，有學生，有路人，談談他們對於現在台灣媒體的看法; 影片後半段則是最精彩的部份，實驗證明之! 他們捏造了兩個故事，傳真給各大電視新聞媒體，最後的結果也真的有記者來採訪，並上到電視新聞當中，由此證明台灣的新聞媒體總是缺乏求證，也太過八卦，太過喜好聳動內容(如靈異等)，以追求高收視綠為目標，而非高品質新聞。我不認為這是只有台灣才有的現象，香港美國英國八卦媒體都是有過之而無不及，但是台灣所存在的問題是，我們沒其他可選了！ 美國有 CNN，英國有 BBC 等專業媒體，但是台灣呢？ 台灣媒體還有個很嚴重的問題，缺乏世界觀! 我記得有次的新聞是在報導台灣的外交部連邦交國位在那個地方都搞不清楚，藉此批評外交部的世界觀，但是我想的是，難道隨便抓個主播來問就知道了？ 每天看他們的新聞內容只有可悲可說，我後來漸漸養成的習慣是，連第四台都不裝了，「不要相信你每天吃的每一粒飯，因為裡面可能滲進了腳尾米」。

腳尾米影片：



另外一則影片是從 TT 那看來的，裡頭是 MSNBC 的晨間新聞 Morning Joe，主播拒絕播放 Paris Hilton 的新聞，撕掉(原本要燒掉的)又碎掉新聞稿，就像 TT 講的，真有 Guts 的主播阿，兩相對照這兩個影片，越顯得台灣媒體的可悲。

資料取自財團法人新聞公害防治基金會，我只做稍微的版面整理：

一、
「馬英九母親跌倒就醫，要大家瞞著馬英九（註：馬英九於見報之後說：寫得很好，唯一就是不是真的）（1月14日中國時報A1、A4）

二、
「大學生因捷運強吻行為，誤信（註：蘋果日報報導）上吊自殺」（1月14日蘋果日報A14）

三、
「吳淑珍美國買超市、趙建銘疑赴越南洗錢與『華國幫合夥投資』」（5月30日聯合晚報3版）

四、
「籲扁下台效應擴大，扁律師、閃靈主唱連署（註：閃靈25日晚即予否認，次日仍予照登）」（7月26日中國時報A1頭題）

五、
「趙建銘賣13克拉巨鑽」（8月18日A1頭題）

六、
「李遠哲為李登輝和施明德連繫中間人（註：遭李遠哲痛斥媒體都在說謊）」（9月22日聯合報A3）

七、
「高鐵模擬地震5公里才煞住（註：違反物理學原理）」（10月23日聯合報A6頭題）

八、
「陳致中滯美 扁當定美國人阿公」（11月27日中國時報A5）

九、
「桃園縣鴨子屠宰場 全是非法的（註：官方後來檢查合法）」（12月22日聯合晚報11版）

十、
「資料外流 暴露高鐵8大缺失（註：事後證明不實）」（12月23日中國時報A8頭題）

『新防會指出，去年各主要報紙的「烏龍新聞」，總計有132 則（中國時報58則、聯合報36則、蘋果日報17則、聯合晚報17則及自由時報4則）。若干報紙錯假新聞不斷，不但有違「正確第一」的新聞工作基本信條，缺乏理性客觀嚴謹的專業態度，並對「爆料」或「傳聞」缺乏「查證」，且有轉述謬誤的報導，明顯悖離專業倫理，衍變成濫用「第四權」，甚且指揮檢調單位辦案和「媒體審判」，凡此不啻自毀公信力。』

剛剛在終極邊疆看到一個有趣的 News filter，簡單的 Javascript bookmarlet 可以幫助你 Mark 出一些特殊字眼，例如：「據透露」、「據了解」、「據指出」等等，這些新聞媒體現在都不做到查詢義務，老是喜歡搞一些爆料新聞，喜歡用聳動標題，一副唯恐天下不亂。有了這個 Filter，就可以讓這些惡質媒體現形。

今天王建民順利拿下了第 17 勝，可喜可賀，雖然王表現優異，但是贏的也是驚險，投了 7 1/3 局下場，下場時以 3 比 1 領先，但是在 9 局時，上來救援的投手又被敲了一支陽春砲，最後洋基以一分之差獲勝，看了真有點心驚驚。

不過今天下午在網路上看到一場 Joe Torre 的賽後訪談，差點讓我吐血，台灣腦殘媒體的愚蠢運作思想已經丟臉丟到國外去啦，塞個大大 Mic (中天新聞的Mic)在 Joe Torre 老爹面前，還被老爹不耐煩的推開不說，你仔細看底下影片，在中後段，台灣媒體的 Mic 忽然不見了！ Why？調大喇叭音量就可發覺，不知哪傳來的聲音『Taiwan media out, please ... 』，這是正義之聲啊，不過真不知到該為這高興還是傷心，我們以王建民為傲，卻以台灣媒體為恥，台灣媒體在自己家裡丟臉也就算了，還跑到國外發光發熱咧，唉～

原始影片

[2006/09/11 Updated]網路爛了一天，終於成功上傳到 YouTube 了：


底下是整段訪談的翻譯，原文取自 ptt FreakC 網友文章：

Reporter: What do you think of Wang's performance?

Torre: I thought he was great. I thought he was great. I mean he, you know, he's been doing that all year... Watch this, young lady. It's squeezed out of here. Come on in here...

Reporter: Joe, ten of his fifteen outs were ground balls, I know that's his deal, but, did you know he's on right away?

Torre: Well, it makes you feel good when you see that. Because you know that he is making his pitch. Yeah, a couple of fastballs... one of them Millar hit, one of them Fahey hit, and the thing is when they score off him, he just goes right back to making better pitches, not did he tries to make bad pitches, but he is a very special youngster with a great deal of poise.

Reporter: Jeter looked like he might have been stepped on by Fahey?

Torre: Yeah, I know. He was fine. I think we just awkward form but obviously... every play, when you, you know, you went three to two, every play is...

Reporter: In the fourth inning, Wang has been hit(記者說成hitted). You think is he okay?

Torre: Yeah, he got hit in the hip, but hs is fine. You know, he got iced up in here, so hopefully there is no feedback from that. We don't anticipate, cause it really wasn't in dangerous area.

Reporter: First inning, Abreu (發音真不標準) and A-Rod and Giambi didn't make the lineup, can you explain the reason?

Torre: Yeah, some body else playing.

Reporter: Is it because you have much a confidence in Wang that those two cannot...

Torre: Oh, no no no no no no no no no, there was a left-hand pitcher pitching who has been very successful againt this, and I just want, you know, to give a couple of right-handers opportunity to do something. Plus the fact that Alex's sick, so he couldn't play. But no, had nothing to do with Wang. I do have a lot of confidence in Wang, but I certainly don't, I don't want to take advantage of him by thinking that I'd put a club that I don't think can win up to.

"Taiwanese media, out, please."

Reporter: Did the doctor see Giambi doing the gain job(?)?

Torre: Yes, and he gave him a shot. So he's probably not gonna be available until we get home. So hopefully this, you know, solves the problem. He seems to be satisfied that, you know, he hit the spot. We are very foutunate, as I said, as the cortisone doctor was here and, you know, during the game he took care.

Reporter: Is there a psychological difference that in a three-one game when you are not sending Mariano in for the ninth?

Torre: Ha ha, yeah, for the manager. You know, but Farnsworth stand this before, and Proctor came in and did his job, Mike Myers did his job. And it was a clean ball game, and I regard. You know, all but the inability the sacriface with Green, but, you know, he caught everything that was hit to him, so that was importnat. Plus, you know, he scored a run and cut a big base hit...

Reporter: He tried to get an extra out too, I think.

Torre: Yeah, I guess, which we hope to carry over to the next inning,
... they weren't gonna buy it.