September 6,2007
Rosebud vs Pink Floyd - Have A Cigar
筆者接觸這首歌曲的情況跟首次聽 Let’s All Chant 差不多﹐不知道歌名﹐也不知道由誰主唱﹐只是電視劇不時用上作為配樂﹐後來無意中從友人借來一盒自錄卡帶﹐才發現這首歌名為 Have A Cigar﹐不過當問起友人有關歌者的資料時﹐對方一點頭緒都沒有。
Have A Cigar - Rosebud
(Roger Water)
Come in here, dear boy, have a cigar
You’re gonna go far, fly high
You’re never gonna die, you’re gonna make it if you try
They’re gonna love you
後來等到90年代﹐筆者開始使用網路﹐並且經常瀏覽外國網站訂購CD﹐才冒了一次險﹐找一張收錄 Have A Cigar 的雜錦CD﹐原來主唱的是 Rosebud﹐來自一張1977年Warner出版的12” Single﹐不過這個 7’47” 的版本比起黑膠6’47” 稍長。但更有趣的地方﹐原來這首跳舞曲﹐竟然是Cover了 Pink Floyd的 Have A Cigar﹐只是它一直重覆唱一段歌詞而已﹐而12”的背面﹐乃是 Pink Floyd的 Disco版本 Money。
Have A Cigar - Pink Floyd﹕原收錄於 Wish You Were Here (1975/Columbia) 專輯中。
(Roger Water)
Come in here, dear boy, have a cigar
You’re gonna go far, fly high
You’re never gonna die, you’re gonna make it if you try
They’re gonna love you
Well I’ve always had a deep respect, and I mean that most sincerely
The band is just fantastic, that is really what I think
Oh by the way, which ones pink?
And did we tell you the name of the game, boy
We call it Riding the Gravy train.
We’re just knocked out.
We heard about the sell out
You gotta get an album out
You owe it to the people.
We’re so happy we can hardly count
Everybody else is just green, have you seen the chart?
It’s a helluva start
It could be made into a monster if we all pull together as a team
And did we tell you the name of the game, boy
We call it riding the Gravy train
Have A Cigar - Rosebud
(Roger Water)
Come in here, dear boy, have a cigar
You’re gonna go far, fly high
You’re never gonna die, you’re gonna make it if you try
They’re gonna love you
後來等到90年代﹐筆者開始使用網路﹐並且經常瀏覽外國網站訂購CD﹐才冒了一次險﹐找一張收錄 Have A Cigar 的雜錦CD﹐原來主唱的是 Rosebud﹐來自一張1977年Warner出版的12” Single﹐不過這個 7’47” 的版本比起黑膠6’47” 稍長。但更有趣的地方﹐原來這首跳舞曲﹐竟然是Cover了 Pink Floyd的 Have A Cigar﹐只是它一直重覆唱一段歌詞而已﹐而12”的背面﹐乃是 Pink Floyd的 Disco版本 Money。
Have A Cigar - Pink Floyd﹕原收錄於 Wish You Were Here (1975/Columbia) 專輯中。
(Roger Water)
Come in here, dear boy, have a cigar
You’re gonna go far, fly high
You’re never gonna die, you’re gonna make it if you try
They’re gonna love you
Well I’ve always had a deep respect, and I mean that most sincerely
The band is just fantastic, that is really what I think
Oh by the way, which ones pink?
And did we tell you the name of the game, boy
We call it Riding the Gravy train.
We’re just knocked out.
We heard about the sell out
You gotta get an album out
You owe it to the people.
We’re so happy we can hardly count
Everybody else is just green, have you seen the chart?
It’s a helluva start
It could be made into a monster if we all pull together as a team
And did we tell you the name of the game, boy
We call it riding the Gravy train
引用URL
http://cgi.blog.roodo.com/trackback/4089015
回應文章 
Roger Water 在Pink Floyd 后期写的歌就偏冷了一点
Rosebud 艺高胆大, 把Have a Cigar 玩出味道来, 热情呀~
Rosebud 艺高胆大, 把Have a Cigar 玩出味道来, 热情呀~
Posted by 飞羊
at September 6,2007 09:25
Dear 飛羊﹐
Rosebud 跟Pink Floyd 的版本其實分別頗大呢。當年聽這首 Disco版﹐感覺很過癮﹐但是現在重溫就覺得頗重覆﹐這是少數我覺得過長的12".
Rosebud 跟Pink Floyd 的版本其實分別頗大呢。當年聽這首 Disco版﹐感覺很過癮﹐但是現在重溫就覺得頗重覆﹐這是少數我覺得過長的12".
Posted by Muzikland
at September 7,2007 03:56
這個disco版本真妙呀!!
Posted by joystrokes
at December 13,2007 01:41
Dear joystrokes,
當初找到Pink Floyd 的 CD 時﹐還以為就是那Disco版﹐但按理實在沒可能﹐後來還是找到Rosebud 的版本。滿以為是兩首不同歌曲﹐沒想到細心比較之下﹐原來真是同一歌曲呢。
歡迎來 Muzikland 玩~
Posted by Muzikland
at December 13,2007 04:31
Take your time to read the credit of this CD single "Rosebud �� Have A Cigar" (UNIDISC & Green Cover), you will get shocked. How come he made disco music in 70\'s & now turns into a prominent soundtrack score composer, Unbelievable!!
Posted by Terence Zhao
at February 28,2008 01:38
Dear Terence Zhao,
我沒有那一張CD Single﹐我有的是另一張CD Compilation 收錄了此曲的。
怎麼了﹐那監制是Arena, A. Puglia 及 T. Perret 啊﹖我不懂呢。
Posted by Muzikland
at February 28,2008 15:14

When I bought this CD single (UNIDISC, green cover), you put on top that one. I got shocked to learn that song was produced by Gabriel Yared.
http://music.msn.com/album/?album=10293633
That\'s unexpected , a prominent soudtrack score composer started his career from disco song. Of coz, it takes to check whether Gabriel Yared has another name to produce this song..or by mistake wrong info on that Unidisc single
cheers
Terence
Posted by terence zhao
at March 3,2008 13:38
Dear Terence Zhao,
我看唱片﹐就沒有發現這名字﹐可能是CD印錯吧﹐也或許是他當年用別名來監制吧。
事實上外國的音樂人雖然在音樂分類中分得很清楚﹐但是卻能接納或製作不同的音樂﹐卻又沒有改變他的音樂定位的﹐不像香港﹐甚麼都來炒雜錦﹐見甚麼音樂時興﹐就把自己扮作成甚麼。數年前﹐一班唱著粵語流行曲的歌手﹐因著一點點民歌熱潮或懷舊氣息﹐便又把自己稱為民歌手﹐真要命。
翻看Gabriel Yared 的資料﹐原來我都看過多部由他配樂的電影﹐包括The English Patient (1996)﹑City of Angels (1998)﹑Message in a Bottle (1999)﹑The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999)﹑Autumn in New York (2000)﹑The Next Best Thing (2000) 等。
Posted by Muzikland
at March 4,2008 05:05

Hi Muzik
My all time favourite soundtrack "Betty Blue" is also done by G. Yared-, sure i watched this movie in last century. haha, it sounds too old & far away, but the score music id definitely timeless
http://www.hmv.co.uk/hmvweb/displayProductDetails.do?ctx=280;-1;-1;-1&sku=247484
Posted by terence zhao
at March 5,2008 15:02
Dear Terence Zhao
哈~光陰似箭啊﹐轉眼間就一個世紀了。
謝謝你的推介~
Posted by Muzikland
at March 6,2008 15:41

