June 20,2009
20090620-【JMPT】Guide to writing a good paper
20090620-【JMPT】Guide to writing a good paper
1.Introduction.
Does the introduction establish a clear need for research work?
2.Analysis of existing work.
Does the paper give a satisfactory summary of existing work in the area and demonstrate that a knowledge gap exists relative to the need established in section 1?
3.Proposal.
Does the paper make a clear proposal of new transferable knowledge?
4.Design of test and implementation.
Does the paper describe an appropriate objective test of the value of the proposed new knowledge?
5.Results and evaluation.
Are the results presented clearly and objectively and are they supported by careful evaluation.
6.Discussion and conclusions.
Do the authors correctly appreciate the value of their work and its implications for others?
[Reference]----------------------------------------
Journal's Reviewers Good Practice Guide
1.Introduction.
Does the introduction establish a clear need for research work?
2.Analysis of existing work.
Does the paper give a satisfactory summary of existing work in the area and demonstrate that a knowledge gap exists relative to the need established in section 1?
3.Proposal.
Does the paper make a clear proposal of new transferable knowledge?
4.Design of test and implementation.
Does the paper describe an appropriate objective test of the value of the proposed new knowledge?
5.Results and evaluation.
Are the results presented clearly and objectively and are they supported by careful evaluation.
6.Discussion and conclusions.
Do the authors correctly appreciate the value of their work and its implications for others?
[Reference]----------------------------------------
Journal's Reviewers Good Practice Guide
引用URL
http://cgi.blog.roodo.com/trackback/9275671
![[Syndicate this site]](http://cdn.rimg.tw/images/blog/rss.gif "Syndicate RSS feed"){kind=small}
![[Syndicate this site]](http://cdn.rimg.tw/images/blog/atom.gif "Syndicate ATOM feed"){kind=small}
