June 25,2006

聽/看兩首反戰歌曲

我曾寫過,Bruce Springsteen 的政治行動是曖昧的,但是他常在現場演唱中展現他的政治態度。在最近為了專輯The Seeger Seession的巡迴演唱會上,他演唱了專輯中沒有收錄的Pete Seeger著名的反越戰歌曲"Bring 'Em Home"。這首歌名恰恰是今年三月紐約一場反戰演唱會的名稱。關於那場演唱會的我的紀錄見這裡
現在,他把他演唱這首歌的版本放在他的網站上免費下載。當然,讓這首反戰歌曲免費下載的動作,政治態度是很明顯的。


另外,我在兩三年前曾經在一個電視節目上看到Pearl Jam現場表演Bob Dylan的經典反戰歌曲Master of War。沒有比那個時刻更讓我深刻感受到搖滾樂的力量了。
當時我並不太記得具體的歌詞-----雖然這首歌絕對是史上最好也最激烈的反戰歌詞。


但即使沒看到歌詞,即使這首歌是不插電演出,但看到Eddie Vedder演唱時沈靜但憤怒的神情,聽到這首歌的極具力量的音樂,真的是讓人無比激動。
重新回去看歌詞,我發現Eddie Vedde的詮釋似乎比Bob Dylan更能展現歌詞的憤怒。


終於,拜Youtube之賜,可以再次看到這個表演。



別忘了配歌詞:


Come you masters of war
You that build all the guns
You that build the death planes
You that build the big bombs
You that hide behind walls
You that hide behind desks
I just want you to know
I can see through your masks

You that never done nothin'
But build to destroy
You play with my world
Like it's your little toy
You put a gun in my hand
And you hide from my eyes
And you turn and run farther
When the fast bullets fly

Like Judas of old
You lie and deceive
A world war can be won
You want me to believe
But I see through your eyes
And I see through your brain
Like I see through the water
That runs down my drain

You fasten the triggers
For the others to fire
Then you set back and watch
When the death count gets higher
You hide in your mansion
As young people's blood
Flows out of their bodies
And is buried in the mud

You've thrown the worst fear
That can ever be hurled
Fear to bring children
Into the world
For threatening my baby
Unborn and unnamed
You ain't worth the blood
That runs in your veins

How much do I know
To talk out of turn
You might say that I'm young
You might say I'm unlearned
But there's one thing I know
Though I'm younger than you
Even Jesus would never
Forgive what you do

Let me ask you one question
Is your money that good
Will it buy you forgiveness
Do you think that it could
I think you will find
When your death takes its toll
All the money you made
Will never buy back your soul

And I hope that you die
And your death'll come soon
I will follow your casket
In the pale afternoon
And I'll watch while you're lowered
Down to your deathbed
And I'll stand o'er your grave
'Til I'm sure that you're dead


Posted by soundfury at 樂多Roodo! │00:33 │回應(13)引用(1)西方樂與怒
樂多分類:文字創作 工具:加入樂多書籤編輯本文
Ads by Roodo! 

引用URL

http://cgi.blog.roodo.com/trackback/1811529
引用列表:
感謝鐵志的推薦與介紹,讓我聽到一流樂團演唱Bob Dylan 的經典反戰歌曲。感謝YouTube,讓我一睹Pearl Jam現場演唱〈Master of War〉的不同MV。
【影音】Pearl Jam〈Master of War〉(在Bob Dylan 出道三十週年的致敬演唱會)【迷幻機器】 at July 6,2006 14:31
回應文章
網路也有5分鐘03秒的影片,等兩個版本下載完再來看有啥增加。
這裡提供下載Youtube影片的解碼網址,像我一樣電腦老舊或想保存影像的朋友,可以使用^_^

下載解碼網址(想下載下列影片,就把下列影片的網址輸入再按鈕即可得到正確網址囉,記得存檔時副檔名若無.flv要自行填上)
http://wish.kuso.cc/cgi-bin/youtube.php

4分鐘32秒
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eh_LEny9IIc&search=Pearl%20Jam%20%20Master%20of%20War

5分鐘版有兩個
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8GHBk_HSXg&search=Pearl%20Jam%20%20Master%20of%20War
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2kk-v7NLr4&search=Pearl%20Jam%20%20Master%20of%20War
Posted by anarch at June 25,2006 18:02
忘了說,「.fly」是特殊格式,如果覺得裝解碼器麻煩的人,可下載FLV Player
http://www.martijndevisser.com/download/flvplayer/flvplayer_setup.exe
Posted by anarch at June 25,2006 18:08
iron點出了一個很有趣的話題:詮釋

同樣一首歌曲,不同的歌手或團體表演起來,效果的確大不相同;延伸的概念可以是,同樣是反戰的概念,什麼樣的音樂形式最具有感染力,又,針對不同的族群傳達概念,要以什麼樣的音樂風格才適合?

手邊有兩套CD(共四張唱片),名叫"Peace Not War",(網站是www.peace-not-war.org),演出藝人洋洋灑灑,從搖滾,重金屬,hip-hop,trip-hop(乾脆統稱urban music),民謠,流行樂...等風格,這樣的編排,很值得細究呢~~

(我想很多藝人你都很熟悉,public enemy,midnight oil,billy bragg,massive attack,ms dynamite,chumbawamba,alabama3, jurassic5,faithless,jane's addiction,sonic youth...這樣的名單,還多少有點像woodstock咧~~)
Posted by SEAN at June 26,2006 02:19
sean,厲害,這兩張你都買了
Posted by iron at June 26,2006 09:42
Pearl Jam 頗喜歡翻唱這首歌的。Bob Dylan 出道三十週年的致敬演唱會上,Eddie Vedder 跟 Mike McCready 就拎著一把木吉他上台唱了這首歌。2004 年的 Vote For Change Tour,在 Pearl Jam 自己的場子有沒有常唱到我是不清楚,至少在 DC 的大會合那場,Pearl Jam 的 set 就又出現了這首歌。

Eddie Vedder 的政治態度一向蠻明確,他的歌聲也一直是憤怒的,你不知道那種情緒什麼時候會爆出來。的確如 iron 所說,他那種沒有保留的憤怒能量,比起 1963 年的 Bob Dylan 來,還要更能傳達這首歌裡面的那股怨悶之氣。
Posted by ludan at June 26,2006 10:33
Ludan,我現在i-Pod中的版本就是那場三十週年演唱會的版本。至於Vote for Change的set,你是怎麼知道的?有畫面可以看嗎?
Posted by iron at June 26,2006 20:45
我也一直在找 Vote for Change 的畫面... 當初是在 VFC DC Finale 那天,在網路上同步收看的。之前還有看到 Sundance channel 重播了一兩次,不過現在應該是沒有了。Maysles 和 Pennebaker 導的 VFC 紀錄片 (不知道是否包括那場演出) 看起來也沒有要發行 DVD 的樣子。

YouTube 上面有少少幾段,但是 Springsteen 的居多。有個大家合唱 "People Have The Power" 的片段: (這場在DC)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpT_FvYpnm8

還有 Boss 和 Neil Young 的 All Along The Watchtower: (這場不知道在哪裡)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNqr2wWIRIo
這個版本很暴力,哇。

其他的畫面遍尋不著,尤其是大家合唱 What's so Funny (About Peach, Love and Understanding) 的那段,以及 Pearl Jam 跟 R.E.M. 的 set。
Posted by ludan at June 27,2006 12:42
我為什麼會把和平打成水蜜桃 =_=
Posted by ludan at June 27,2006 12:49
上面我貼的那兩個5分鐘版本,就是Bob Dylan 出道三十週年的致敬演唱會嗎?
我覺得5分鐘這版本聲音與影像搭配起來,真的很有力量,看了很感動。
Posted by anarch at July 4,2006 04:14
anarch,是的。而且可以看到不同年齡的Eddie Vedder
Posted by iron at July 4,2006 06:31
我注意到的關鍵字是【ipod】,不知道iron買的可是U2版?
Posted by 豬小草 at July 6,2006 23:04
沒這麼炫啦
我是Nano而已
Posted by iron at July 7,2006 13:01
Posted by snow at July 19,2006 14:30